This blog post is the first in a series on child care ratios. First Five Nebraska will provide more information on state and regional comparisons in the next blog in this series.
As policymakers around the country explore ways to expand child care capacity and reduce operating costs, proposals to relax staff-to-child ratio requirements have emerged as one potential approach. These changes would allow individual caregivers to supervise more children at a time, with the intended goal of increasing the number of available child care spaces.
While these proposals are often driven by a desire to improve access and affordability, changing Nebraska’s existing standards without addressing the broader challenges facing the state’s child care system could have unintended consequences. Increasing the number of children under a caregiver’s supervision could compromise child safety, place additional demands on an already strained workforce and undermine families’ confidence in the quality of care their children receive.
Expanding child care capacity requires more than increasing the number of children permitted in existing settings. Without corresponding investments in the workforce and the resources necessary to provide quality care, changes to caregiver-to-child ratios alone are unlikely to deliver the affordable, accessible and high-quality child care Nebraska families need.
Statutory and Administrative Landscape
Federal law requires states and territories to establish standards for staff-to-child ratios and group sizes to ensure the safety, well-being and development of children in child care programs.
In adhering to these safety goals, Nebraska’s ratios have been set through the Nebraska Department of Health and Human Services’ rulemaking process. Such staff-to-child ratios are generally consistent with national averages, which we will explore in more detail in the next blog post in this series on ratios.
The following are current Nebraska ratios for child care centers:
Infants (6 weeks up to 18 months old)* 1:4
Toddlers (18 months up to 3 years old) 1:6
Preschoolers (3 years old) 1:10
Preschoolers (4 through 5 years old) 1:12
School ages (6 through 12 years old) 1:15
*Maximum group size of 12
Note: Maximum group size means the total number of children permitted in a single classroom or defined care space at the same time, regardless of how many adults are present. Most states have group size requirements for all ages, while Nebraska only has these requirements for infants.
Family child care homes (FCCH) provide care to mixed age groups and are licensed into two tiers. They are regulated for the maximum number of children served:
FCCH I: 8-10*
FCCH II: 10-12*
*Depends on certain conditions related to infants and school-age children
Key Concerns
The following are key concerns First Five Nebraska would have with any proposed changes to ratios:
Reduced supervision and safety: As the number of children assigned to each caregiver increases, it becomes more difficult to supervise every child, respond promptly to emergencies and manage competing needs. This is particularly concerning for infants and toddlers, who require more frequent individual care and close supervision. When caregivers are responsible for more children, direct supervision drops, which increases the likelihood of injuries, choking incidents or emergency health issues.
Greater strain on the child care workforce: Nebraska’s child care providers already face significant challenges recruiting and retaining qualified staff while managing rising operating costs. In fact, the current child care industry turnover rate in Nebraska is 35%. Increasing the number under each caregiver’s supervision could intensify workloads, contribute to burnout and make it more difficult to hire and retain experienced staff.
Uncertain benefits for families and affordability: Unfortunately, additional capacity does not necessarily translate to lower costs for families or greater access to care. Providers face a range of fixed and variable expenses, and any potential savings may be needed to offset existing financial pressures rather than reduce tuition. Without complementary policies that address the underlying economics of child care, ratio changes alone are unlikely to produce meaningful improvements in affordability and accessibility.
Conclusion
Nebraska's child care challenges require solutions that expand access and improve affordability while preserving the safety and quality families expect. Instead of modifying existing resources, we should focus on removing the barriers that constrain child care availability, including workforce shortages, administrative inefficiencies and the financial pressures facing providers and families.
As the Legislature prepares for the 2027 session, First Five Nebraska looks forward to working with state senators to advance practical, evidence-informed solutions that strengthen Nebraska's child care system and ensure more families can access affordable, high-quality care.